The following is my direct response to
Mary who is much cooler than she thinks she is. She links to a list of books she wants to read/ is reading, and I made a comment to her about the first book of the Belgariad, by David Eddings, which I found on that list.
Basically, I don't recommend it.
In fact, that series is on my list of "If this crap can get published, so can I."
Not necessarily because I think I'm better than David Eddings. In fact, I think he's got a nice, addictive writing style. He also has one or two original ideas. These are both great things. My problem is in what he does with them.
You see, apparently Mary's friend and fellow blogger
BarcodeKing recommended that she read the first book and not read further if she didn't like it. But Mary - please beware!
The first book is really not half bad.
But - it never happens again. Especially not in the Belgariad series. Some of his other series might start out OK. I don't know, I only tried one other series and found it just as lame as the Belgariad.
See, I was seriously angry when I finished that series. The first book lulled me into a false sense of creativity and excitement. I picked up the next book in the series and found it did nothing to really improve, in fact, it sagged a bit from the first one. The next one sagged even more, and so on. I don't remember how many books are in that series. Seems like 5 but it could have been 3 and seemed like 5. Any way, the whole series just dwindles away to nothing. It's just a whimpering pile of goo by the end.
I confess I still laugh at the ending to the series, but not because it was intentionally funny. Because it was just so bad.
And everyone who is shocked at my scathing review, please remember - this author is quite successful. Many, many other people like him quite a lot. He's making a nice living off of Fantasy books, and I envy him that. I'll be upfront on that point. If I had written those books, I'd be proud of them too. But in my heart, I'd know I could do better. David Eddings, I know you can do better. Don't keep on churning out the same old crap. Sit down and take a while to develop something that is up to your full potential.